Should journalists change quotes? Ever?


Some of you have said something similar to this in class:

The truth, according to writer and journalist Janet Malcolm, is “messy, incoherent, aimless, boring, absurd…the truth does not make a good story; that’s why we have art.” She also compared accuracy to a shapeless housecoat.

But what about people’s quotes?  How should a journalist deal with editing messy or incoherent or downright boring quotes from his or her interviewees?  Is it doing the subjects a favor or a disservice to clean up their words a bit?  Or is that ethically wrong?  Where is the line?

Jon Franklin, a  a two-time Pulitzer winner who now teaches journalism and creative writing at the University of Oregon, says this:

“I’ve changed quotes and I’ve been accused of changing quotes, but I have never been accused of changing a quote I actually changed…People don’t say what they mean, and they expect you to quote what they mean, not what they say. That is slippery, but it’s the reality.”

Susan Feeney, a national political reporter for the Dallas Morning News, says this:

“You can’t. You can’t fix quotes. Period…If somebody speaks in a way in which quoting them is incomprehensible, you don’t use the quote. You use partial quotes. I don’t fix them. Ever.”

What do you think?

To find out more about this debate- read an article that quotes many journalists (correctly?  lets hope!) here.


2,429 thoughts on “Should journalists change quotes? Ever?

  1. Ohio Car dealer open Sundays
    Boardman Nissan is always looking for ways to give you something more. We bring you a wide selection of the newest and latest Nissan models and vehicles, and we always take pride in our extensive selection of used vehicles. Of course, within our selection of used vehicles you can find multiple manufacturers, but we always strive to heavily feature the Nissan brand, after all, that brand could be the primary reason that brought you in here in the first place.

  2. new Buick dealership Harrison, AR
    Our service department is staffed with factory trained and certified technicians ready to provide the best automotive service for our customers. We repair any make or model, even if you didn’t buy it from us. Our state-of-the-art-facility features the most current diagnostic and repair equipment available and our team will deliver efficient and quality vehicle care.Our parts department is stocked with genuine GM parts to keep your vehicle running at its optimum performance level.

  3. Chicago automotive marketing company
    Aspen’s senior management team has over 100 years combined retail experience at the automotive dealership level. The automotive industry has undergone several changes over the years, yet Aspen continues our unprecedented growth and remains one of the world’s top 10 direct marketing companies. Because we have walked in your shoes, we understand your daily routine and what it takes to execute a successful direct mail promotion.

  4. Used Honda dealer Harrisburg
    At Faulkner Honda our motto is “Family First,” which is your assurance that each and every employee is here to meet your needs in a manner that really makes you feel like you are part of our Faulkner Family.Faulkner Honda is a proud member of the largest auto dealer group in Pennsylvania with over 80 years of experience, and we are still family owned.

  5. psychic medium experiences
    Matthew Fraser is an Internationally renowned psychic/medium and author of “The Secrets to Unlocking Your Psychic Ability”. He has conducted thousands of readings around the world, reconnecting friends & family with the spirits of those who are no longer with us. His messages of hope, comfort and reassurance have touched the lives of all who meet him, making Matt one of the most gifted and genuine psychics living today.

  6. Camp Hill Used Nissan car & truck dealer
    Growing from a single car dealership in Philadelphia into one of the largest family-owned automotive group of dealerships in the United States, we have never wavered from our commitment to outstanding service, value and the highest standards of integrity. We continue to go the extra mile for our community, customers and friends.

  7. Pittsburgh used cars Cheap
    At Baierl Budget Cars, we know there’s an opportunity to improve the customer experience to set ourselves apart. Our mission is to be better than anyone else in the industry and guarantee your ownership experience is second to none.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *